Anthony Cartee

  • The Trademark Registration Process – Part 1

    The Trademark Registration Process – Part 1

    The Trademark Registration Process Trademark Registration Process – How does one go about registering a trademark?  What are some of the requirements in order to obtain protection?  There are many steps and several issues to consider, but overall the process is not arcane or excessively complicated (unlike, for instance, the steps necessary to obtain a utility patent).  Federal Trademark registration is handled by the United States Patent and Trademark Office. Trademark Search To be registrable, a trademark cannot already be owned by someone else.  Thus the first step is to conduct a trademark search.  Various private companies and even some attorneys offer… Read More

  • Nominative Fair Use – Swarovski Aktiengesellschaft v. Building No. 19

    Nominative Fair Use – Swarovski Aktiengesellschaft v. Building No. 19

    Swarovski Aktiengesellschaft v. Building No. 19 – Nominative Fair Use Nominative Fair Use – This case highlighted the fact that trademark law is constantly evolving – the major issue was so-called “nominative” use of a trademark, i.e., use of a trademark to refer to the trademark holder’s own goods in an advertisement by a seller not affiliated with the trademark holder.  The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit recently decided the very interesting case of Swarovski Aktiengesellschaft v. Building No. 19.  As the First Circuit noted, different circuits of the United States have fashioned different rules for dealing with… Read More

  • Trade Dress – Does it Have to Have Secondary Meaning?

    Trade Dress – Does it Have to Have Secondary Meaning?

    Trade Dress – Does it Have to Have Secondary Meaning? In a previous post we’ve touched on the idea of trade dress – the packaging of a product, and its “look and feel.”  The configuration of the product itself, such as the shape of a bottle, may also be considered trade dress.  Trade dress is protectable under the Lanham Act as something of value that may indicate the source or origin of a product.  Previously we mentioned two additional requirements: the trade dress cannot be functional, and it must be distinctive.  For example the color and shape of a bottle of Tide… Read More

  • Titles of Artistic Works – Implications of Dastar

    Titles of Artistic Works – Implications of Dastar

    Titles of Artistic Works – Implications of Dastar Artistic Works – The United States Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit recently decided the case of Eastland Music Group v. Lionsgate Entertainment.  This action for trademark infringement, and the court’s subsequent analysis helped settle an issue long weighed by courts and commentators – to what extent may the title of an artistic work infringe the trademark of another?  The case also developed the implications of the famous (or infamous) case of Dastar Corp. v. Twentieth Century Fox, one of the most important trademark decisions of the 21st century to date. Background of… Read More

  • When Terms are Merely Descriptive Part 2

    When Terms are Merely Descriptive Part 2

    When Terms are Merely Descriptive Part 2 Merely Descriptive Part 2 – Today we continue our discussion of certain interesting topics within the larger question of when certain terms are classified as merely descriptive.  The classification of a term as a descriptive mark carries with it the consequence that the mark receives no protection whatsoever unless secondary meaning can be demonstrated. We previously discussed the merits of foreign words and personal names as potential trademarks and concluded that they are subject to some special rules and tests by the USPTO and the judicial system.  Today we continue our discussion with the examination of… Read More

  • Attorneys Fees & Lanham Act

    Attorneys Fees & Lanham Act

    Attorneys Fees Under the Lanham Act Attorneys Fees – Today we look at Aviva USA Corporation v. Vazirani, a case recently heard by the United States District Court for the District of Arizona.  Interestingly, Arizona is located in the famous (or infamous) 9th Circuit of the United States, the largest circuit including areas as diverse as Alaska, Oregon, California, and of course, Arizona.  This case explores the issue of when it is appropriate to award attorney’s fees to the prevailing party in an action for trademark infringement. Attorneys Fees, Generally In the British judicial system the rule is that the losing party… Read More

  • When are Terms Merely Descriptive? Part I

    When are Terms Merely Descriptive? Part I

    When are Terms Merely Descriptive? Part I We have previously discussed trademark issues with descriptive terms.  To recap, terms that are merely descriptive receive the least amount of trademark protection. A descriptive term, such as “Fish-Fry” – generally does not qualify for protection unless the term has acquired some form of secondary meaning in the perception of the relevant consumer base in the relevant market for the product. Today, we address an even more basic question – what are some of the grounds for a mark to fall into the dreaded “merely distinctive” (merely descriptive) category?  And are there any ways out? … Read More

  • When is it Ok to Use Another’s Artwork?

    When is it Ok to Use Another’s Artwork?

    When is it Ok to Use Another’s Artwork? Use Another’s Artwork? – Today we take a look at the case of Seltzer v. Green Day and examine the circumstances under which one may use the creative works of another person. The major issue in the case was fair use of copyrighted material – in this case: artwork. The topic ties in nicely with last week’s post, which dealt with Fair Use in the trademark realm. Background of the Artwork Copyright Case Plaintiff Seltzer is an artist, illustrator and photographer. Defendant Green Day is an iconic rock and roll band. In… Read More

  • Fair Use – Descriptive Marks

    Fair Use – Descriptive Marks

    Fair Use of Descriptive Marks Fair Use – Today we take a look at the fair use defense to allegations of trademark infringement.  Beware!  The fair use defense in trademarks is quite different from its more notorious cousin, the fair use defense in copyright actions.  In a previous post we looked at Zatarain’s v. Oak Grove Smokehouse to learn the applicable standards for when secondary meaning allows for a merely descriptive trademark to be enforced.  Today we return to the case featuring delicious battered and fried chicken and fish to learn more about fair use and its role in the final disposition of… Read More

  • Preliminary Injunctions – Trademark Infringement

    Preliminary Injunctions – Trademark Infringement

    Preliminary Injunctions for Trademark Infringement Preliminary Injunctions – When you accuse someone of infringing your valuable trademark, what actually happens?  In American Rena International Corp v. Sis-Joyce International the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued a ruling that very clearly articulated the standards for what is known as preliminary injunctions. Preliminary Injunctions, Generally Imagine a dispute between two parties.  Party P, the plaintiff, accuses party D, the defendant, of doing something wrong – let’s hypothetically say that D has taken to shooting a shotgun into the air in his own backyard which is next door to P’s duck… Read More